NHL game preview · Columbus Blue Jackets vs New York Islanders

Islanders' goaltending and finishing against Columbus's four-game skid and scoring struggles

The Islanders are favoured at -139, but their record leans on a 91% team save percentage and 11.9% shooting while their shot share ranks 28th. Columbus has lost four straight and scores 2.5 goals per game, rank 27. The price is steady despite heavy one-sided support for New York.

Key numbers

Spread (NYI)
-1.5
Total
5.5
Moneyline
CBJ +120 · NYI -145
Spread bets / money (NYI)
22% / 24%
Over bets / money
86% / 84%

Consensus across 32 sportsbooks.

Columbus comes in at 7-11-0 on a four-game losing streak, while the Islanders sit at 9-6-4 and are favoured at -139 on the moneyline. The central question is whether New York's goaltending and finishing, which carry its record, outweigh underlying shot numbers that rank poorly, against a Columbus offence that has struggled to score.

The Islanders' results rest on percentages. Their team save percentage is 91%, rank 3, and they shoot 11.9% as a team. Their shot share is 47.1%, rank 28, and they generate 25.6 shots per game while allowing 28.7. That mix can hold or fade, and nothing here says which. Recent defence has slipped: they have allowed 3.6 goals per game over the last 10 games, against 2.95 for the season, rank 10.

Columbus has nearly the opposite profile in places. Its shot share is 49.5%, rank 18, yet it scores 2.5 goals per game, rank 27, and the figure is the same over its last 10 games. The defence is more respectable at 3.22 allowed per game, rank 14, and 2.9 over the last 10, but a team save percentage of 89%, rank 20, limits how much that helps. Sean Monahan is out for the Blue Jackets, and Zach Werenski holds Columbus's highest posted shots line at 3.5, matching Matthew Schaefer's for New York.

Special teams give New York a modest edge. Its penalty kill is 85.9%, rank 4, while Columbus's power play converts 18.2%, rank 23. The reverse matchup is less lopsided: Columbus kills penalties at 73.5%, rank 22, but the Islanders' power play is 17%, rank 25, so that weakness may go unexploited.

Recent form is ugly for both sides in different ways. Columbus has failed to cover in four straight, is 6-12 against the spread this season, and has lost four straight as an away underdog. The Islanders have lost four straight at home, though they arrive off a 6-2 road win in which Schaefer had three assists. They won three of the last four meetings, including 4-3 at Columbus and 1-0 at home on 2026-03-22, while Columbus took the 4-2 game on 2025-12-28. Logan Stanley and Jean-Gabriel Pageau are day-to-day for New York.

The price has been steady. The moneyline opened at New York -136 and Columbus +113, a move too small to matter. Bets are 83% on the Islanders and money 78%, heavy one-sided support that did not shift the number. The puck line is Islanders -1.5 at +179, and the total is 5.5, unchanged, with the Over at -119 and the Under at -103. The evidence conflicts: the Islanders' save percentage and finishing favour them on results, while shot share and recent goals allowed point to a closer game. Neither team has confirmed a starting goalie.

Columbus Blue Jackets vs New York Islanders: FAQ

When is Columbus Blue Jackets vs New York Islanders?

Columbus Blue Jackets at New York Islanders kicks off Tuesday, November 17, 2026 at 7:00 PM ET.

Who is favored in Columbus Blue Jackets vs New York Islanders?

New York Islanders is a 1.5-point favorite (consensus across 32 sportsbooks).

What is the over/under for Columbus Blue Jackets vs New York Islanders?

The consensus total is 5.5.

Where is the public betting on Columbus Blue Jackets vs New York Islanders?

On the spread, 22% of bets and 24% of the money are on New York Islanders; 78% of bets and 76% of the money are on Columbus Blue Jackets.

AI-assisted analysis for entertainment. Prices move; check your book before you bet. 21+. Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER.